I think the squicky RPS is the kind that feels too real, you know? That actually reads like they expect the real people to do this stuff.

The decent RPS just kind of pretends that people like J2 are characters just as much as Sam and Dean and as such are ficable. You suspend your disbelief and just enjoy two hot people enjoying each other, like you would for slash or cestfic.

/shrug/

Yeah, I overthink everything. What else is new? /grins/